Delicious Italian Restaurants in Sonoma County

Raviolis in Domenica's Sauce from Catelli's

Sonoma County enjoys a rich Italian heritage, which began when immigrants moved into the region in the 1800s to do timber and railroad work. As they settled, they also built wineries and restaurants, and shared their excellent Italian food with the world.

Below is a selection of popular Sonoma County eateries where the Italian tradition continues. For other options, find more Sonoma County restaurants here.

Ca’Bianca Italian Restaurant, Santa Rosa

The restaurant is set in a vicotrian house
Ca’Bianca Italian Restaurant

The grand old mansion in old town Santa Rosa is home to excellent Italian cuisine, showcasing various regions, crafted by owners and husband-and-wife Marco Diana and Karin Hoehne.

Recipes draw from Milano in the north to Sicily in the south, for dishes like seared ahi with home-made ravioli in almond sauce; Sardinian semolina gnocchi with porcini and slowly braised beef; or roasted breast of duck served with sautéed spinach and fingerling potatoes.

Dressing up isn’t necessary, but makes the meal more fun, as you’ll feel extra glamorous in the old-school sophisticated setting with chandeliers, white tablecloths, antique furniture, and gracious gardens.

Rosso Pizzeria & Wine Bar, Santa Rosa

At the entry, a bar with a large flat-screen TV shows European soccer, and the loud music ranges from Rick James to Rat Pack oldies. You’ll also find a selection of high-style magazines, plus crayons for the kids. To say that “everyone goes here” is accurate, and the long waits for a table will prove it.

Think rustic Italian food: stellar salumi, antipasti, salads, piadine (salad-topped flatbread), and nightly specials like oven-roasted Dungeness crab or risotto. Another showstopper is the bufala mozzarella made with real Italian water buffalo milk, which makes a lovely snack paired with an excellent chopped Caesar decorated in mild Gorgonzola, fresh anchovy, and thick lemony dressing spiked with hot Calabrian chile paste.

But what everyone really comes for is the pizza, its crisp crust baked to a puffy-edged finish in the wood-burning oven, with toppings such as McEvoy Ranch EVOO, and Sonoma-grown greens and eggs.

Catelli’s, Geyserville

Burrata, proscuitto, and arugula served as an appetizer in Sonoma County
Catelli’s

Catelli’s is Geyserville’s newest and oldest restaurant. Although it opened under that name in early 2010, it actually debuted as Catelli’s the Rex restaurant in 1936.The menu is a nod to the good-old-days, too. Nonnie’s minestrone is just like it might have been when Grandma Catelli served it to the young Domenica, now chef, slow-simmering her own hearty stock of vegetables and cannellini, navy and garbanzo beans.

The meat ravioli is Grandmother’s recipe, too, bringing a big plate of a dozen delicate pasta pockets smothered in Domenica’s sauce of tomato, fresh herbs and plenty of garlic. 

Mamma Tanino’s Ristorante, Sonoma

It’s a must for any great Italian restaurant: a chef who was born in Italy. So it is with chef Gaetano Patrinostro, who sources Sonoma County products plus imports from his homeland to prepare authentic Italian cuisine in this cozy trattoria just west of Sonoma Plaza.

White tablecloths and dark wood lend an old-world charm in the no-fuss, casual dining room, where servers are quick to keep everyone’s wine glasses filled. The menu is straightforward and pleasing, with favorites such as spicy bucatini amatriciana tossed with pancetta, onion, chili flake, and tomato sauce; chicken marsala; and a daily special like Friday’s spaghetti and meatballs.

Canneti Roadhouse Italiana, Forestville

A pasta dish with fresh, spring vegetables
Canneti Roadhouse Italiana

Chef Francesco Torre hails from the coast of Tuscany, and brought his authentic recipes with him, creating bold, rustic flavors like the gooey, salty joy that is the local crispy anchovy melt with house-pulled mozzarella and capers.

At the heart of his eatery is a pasta-making machine, imported from his homeland, and used for cozy comforts like maccheroni ladled in Tuscan meat sauce, or a more refined petite Alaskan halibut crepe brightened with carrots, pea leaves and crispy guanciale.

The setting is so simple it’s almost industrial, with rough brick walls, and farmhouse wood tables and chairs, while the patio out back beckons for a relaxed meal nestled beneath towering trees. But the food can compete with the best in big cities, such as a dramatic, mouthwatering beet linguine tumbled with Manila clams, red chard, and garlic tops.

Diavola Pizzeria & Salumeria, Geyserville

A chef stands next to the pizza oven where pizzass are ready to be cooked
Diavola Pizzeria & Salumeria

You know chef Dino Bugica is serious, as he hand-pulls pizza dough, scatters on artisanal toppings, then feeds the pies into a wood-burning oven topped with a growling, tusked pig sculpture.

The pizzas emerge charred and golden, crisp and pillowy, and generously decorated with housemade sausage chunks, red onion and flurries of white pecorino cheese shavings, or juicy Lingurian clams, broccoli raab, parsley, tomato, pecorino, herbs, and garlic.

Other delights include red beet antipasti sweetened with sheep’s milk ricotta, a big bowl of seafood alla Diavola brimming with citrus-kissed squid, shrimp, black eyed peas, mushy-mild anchovies alla povera, and buttery cannellini; and dessert of basil panna cotta.

Cucina Paradiso Ristorante Italiano, Petaluma

Shrimp served on top of pasta served with wine
Cucina Paradiso Ristorante Italiano

Chef-owner Dennis Hernandez worked at top San Francisco restaurants before setting out to establish his dream of an Italian kitchen in Wine Country.

Now his dining room, dressed in warm gold tones and rich wood, sets the romantic mood for classics like homemade soft polenta topped with scattered mushrooms and Italian cheeses; an authentic Caesar with anchovies; and pork tenderloin sautéed with porcini, prosciutto, brandy, and mustard.

Delicate pastas are a particular highlight, such as the homemade ravioli stuffed with roast duck in sundried tomato, pine nut, and basil sauce; or gnocchi in creamy gorgonzola walnut sauce. Even the most simple angel hair is heavenly, perfectly al dente and moistened with fresh tomato, basil, garlic, and olive oil.

Risibisi, Petaluma

A dish of pasta and clams
Risibisi

Owner Marco Palmieri’s Sonoma-style Italian cuisine takes a delightful twist with signatures like grilled asparagus paired with duck egg, Calabrian chili-pancetta vinaigrette and crispy shallot, or seared duck breast in a mélange of carrot fregola, braised radish, roasted baby carrot, and cardamom-duck sauce.

The mood is comfortable trattoria, cocooned within brick walls, warm wood, a big, welcoming bar, and a clientele of lots of regulars who know to ask about the pasta of the day.

The everyday menu brims with excellent pastas, as well, like a sumptuous strozzapreti tumbled with braised pork shoulder, house-made mustard, spinach, and a surprise punch of fresh horseradish root; or house-made gnocchi smothered in braised wild boar ragu, and shaved Parmigiano. The chef also prepares gluten-free pastas, with remarkable flavor.

Union Hotel Restaurants

The outside of the restaurant is flanked by redwoods in Occidental
Occidental Union Hotel Restaurant

And last but not least on this list, try one or both of the Union Hotel Restaurants. The local Gonnella family has called the Union Hotel Restaurant in Occidental their own for five generations, while the newer Union Hotel Restaurant East Santa Rosa, which has a sprawling patio, is a popular spot with couples and families. 

Written by Sonoma Insider Carey Sweet

You Might Also Like

Comstock Wines, Healdsburg
Wineries

As you plan your upcoming Sonoma County excursion, you imagine that your Wine Country ramble will unfold in a certain…

Hamel Family Wines, wine tasting and non-alcoholic tasting
Wineries

With a massive flood of zero-proof beverages recently hitting the market, it’s become fairly easy to find nonalcoholic alternatives on…

Girls Getaway in Sonoma County
Food & Wine

Winter might be considered the off-season for many of the world’s hottest travel destinations, but a Wine Country visit between…

Farmhouse Inn exterior
Food & Wine

From Ben Affleck and Gwyneth Paltrow to Justin and Hailey Bieber, you may bump into a few celebrities at Sonoma…

The Valley of the Moon Vintage Festival (Julie Vader/For Sonoma Index-Tribune)
Events & Festivals

The finest of Sonoma County’s art and agriculture will be on full display this autumn in a myriad of both…

Couple at beach with dog
Outdoor Activities

Find hidden gems, outdoor adventures and more with tips from those who know the coast better than anyone: The locals….

Buena Vista Winery barrels
Wineries

The term “ghost wineries” may conjure images of restless spirits wandering winery corridors, but it doesn’t refer to haunted vineyard…

Dishes from Farmhouse in Sonoma County
Restaurants

Underground pop-ups, food-centric wine bars, and farm-to-table favorites are gathering all kinds of momentum in Sonoma County. For this list,…

Goose and Fern Fish and Chips
Restaurants

Sonoma County has a growing number of restaurants that are staying open later. If you find yourself out after 9…

Wineries

One of the satisfying perks of the 21st century is being able to order just about anything and have it…

See What’s Happening

Share your experience using #SonomaCounty or #LifeOpensUp